Show Posts
1
Rules Questions / Threat Zone one more time
« on: August 22, 2020, 10:18:54 PM »
Hello guys,
I feel (almost) sorry to ask about threat zones one more time.
In a game a situation more or less like in the diagram came up. It was ruled that the knight element can neither attack the Cv nor the horde or the Psiloi.
This does not satisfy me, I think in real life the Kn would be able to attack someone. So I have three questions:
1. Did we interpret the rules correctly?
2. If yes, does that bother you? Do you see a problem here?
3. If you think 1 is correct, without regard to question 2, what would happen if there was one additional rule, something like this: "After contacting an enemy element a group or single element only reacts to that element's Threat Zone." The idea is, that in situations like this multiple threat zones and/or geometry would not hinder an attack if contact with one enemy element is possible. After that, further rules regarding moving obstructing elements would come into play....
Thanks a lot for your thoughts here
I feel (almost) sorry to ask about threat zones one more time.
In a game a situation more or less like in the diagram came up. It was ruled that the knight element can neither attack the Cv nor the horde or the Psiloi.
This does not satisfy me, I think in real life the Kn would be able to attack someone. So I have three questions:
1. Did we interpret the rules correctly?
2. If yes, does that bother you? Do you see a problem here?
3. If you think 1 is correct, without regard to question 2, what would happen if there was one additional rule, something like this: "After contacting an enemy element a group or single element only reacts to that element's Threat Zone." The idea is, that in situations like this multiple threat zones and/or geometry would not hinder an attack if contact with one enemy element is possible. After that, further rules regarding moving obstructing elements would come into play....
Thanks a lot for your thoughts here